Looking for the best Italian carryout in Ithaca, New York? You've come to the right place! Ithaca boasts a vibrant food scene, and when it comes to Italian cuisine, several establishments offer delicious and convenient carryout options. Whether you're craving a classic pasta dish, a hearty slice of pizza, or a flavorful Italian sandwich, Ithaca's Italian carryout spots have something to satisfy every palate. Let's dive into some of the top contenders for the best Italian carryout in this charming New York town.

Top Italian Carryout Restaurants in Ithaca

1. Pasta Plus: Your Go-To for Classic Italian**

When discussing Italian carryout, Pasta Plus immediately springs to mind. This local favorite has been serving the Ithaca community for years, earning a reputation for quality and consistency. Their menu is packed with classic Italian dishes, all available for convenient carryout.

Pasta Dishes: From creamy fettuccine Alfredo to robust spaghetti Bolognese, Pasta Plus offers a wide array of pasta dishes. Each dish is prepared with fresh ingredients and attention to detail, ensuring a flavorful and satisfying meal. Don't miss their lasagna, a customer favorite known for its rich layers of pasta, meat, and cheese.

Pizza: Pizza is a staple of any Italian carryout, and Pasta Plus does not disappoint. Their pizzas are made with hand-tossed dough, homemade sauce, and a generous topping of cheese and your choice of ingredients. Whether you prefer a simple Margherita or a loaded supreme, you're sure to find a pizza that hits the spot.

Sandwiches and More: In addition to pasta and pizza, Pasta Plus also offers a selection of Italian sandwiches, salads, and appetizers. Their meatball sub is a particular standout, featuring juicy meatballs smothered in marinara sauce and served on a toasted roll. With such a diverse menu, Pasta Plus is the perfect choice for a quick and delicious Italian meal on the go.

2. Gorgers Subs: Italian Sandwiches Done Right

While Gorgers Subs is primarily known for its creative and delicious subs, their Italian-inspired options are not to be overlooked. If you're in the mood for a hearty and flavorful Italian sandwich, Gorgers is the place to go. Guys, trust me, you will love this place.

The Godfather: This signature sub features a mouthwatering combination of ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Italian dressing. It's a true Italian classic, packed with flavor and sure to satisfy even the heartiest appetite.

The Mama Mia: Another Italian-inspired favorite, The Mama Mia features grilled chicken, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and pesto. It's a lighter but equally delicious option, perfect for a quick and satisfying lunch or dinner.

Custom Creations: In addition to their signature subs, Gorgers also allows you to create your own custom sandwich. Choose from a wide variety of meats, cheeses, and toppings to build the perfect Italian masterpiece.

3. Sal's Pizzeria: A Slice of Italy in Ithaca

No discussion of Italian carryout would be complete without mentioning Sal's Pizzeria. This family-owned establishment has been serving authentic New York-style pizza to the Ithaca community for decades. With its thin crust, tangy sauce, and generous toppings, Sal's pizza is a true taste of Italy.

Classic Pizzas: From the classic Margherita to the pepperoni-packed pie, Sal's offers a wide variety of traditional pizzas. Each pizza is made with fresh ingredients and baked to perfection in a brick oven, ensuring a crispy crust and gooey cheese.

Specialty Pizzas: In addition to their classic offerings, Sal's also offers a selection of specialty pizzas. The White Pizza, topped with ricotta cheese, garlic, and olive oil, is a particular standout. Or try the Veggie Pizza, loaded with fresh vegetables and a light sprinkle of mozzarella.

Other Italian Favorites: While pizza is the main attraction at Sal's, they also offer a selection of other Italian favorites, including calzones, strombolis, and pasta dishes. Their calzones are particularly popular, filled with ricotta cheese, mozzarella, and your choice of fillings.

4. Sammy's Italian Cuisine: Authentic Flavors, Convenient Carryout

For those seeking a more traditional Italian carryout experience, Sammy's Italian Cuisine is an excellent choice. This restaurant prides itself on serving authentic Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their menu features a wide variety of pasta dishes, entrees, and appetizers, all available for convenient carryout.

Pasta Perfection: Sammy's offers a wide range of pasta dishes, from classic spaghetti and meatballs to more sophisticated creations like lobster ravioli. Each dish is prepared with care and attention to detail, ensuring a flavorful and satisfying meal. Don't miss their homemade gnocchi, a customer favorite known for its light and fluffy texture.

Entrees to Delight: In addition to pasta, Sammy's also offers a selection of Italian entrees, including chicken parmesan, veal marsala, and eggplant rollatini. Each entree is served with a side of pasta or vegetables, making for a complete and satisfying meal.

Appetizers and Sides: Round out your meal with one of Sammy's delicious appetizers or sides. Their garlic knots are a particular favorite, served warm and dripping with garlic butter. Or try the bruschetta, topped with fresh tomatoes, basil, and balsamic glaze.

Tips for Ordering Italian Carryout in Ithaca

Check Online Reviews: Before placing your order, take a few minutes to read online reviews. This can give you a better sense of the restaurant's quality, service, and overall customer satisfaction.

Consider Location and Hours: Choose a restaurant that is conveniently located and open during the hours you need it. This will ensure that your carryout experience is as smooth and hassle-free as possible.

Ask About Specials: Many Italian restaurants offer daily or weekly specials. Be sure to ask about these specials when placing your order, as they can be a great way to save money or try something new.

Order Online or by Phone: Most Italian restaurants in Ithaca offer online ordering or phone ordering. Choose the method that is most convenient for you.

Specify Pickup Time: When placing your order, be sure to specify your desired pickup time. This will help the restaurant ensure that your food is fresh and ready when you arrive.

Enjoying Your Italian Carryout at Home

Once you've picked up your Italian carryout, it's time to enjoy it at home! Here are a few tips for making the most of your meal:

Set the Table: Create a cozy and inviting atmosphere by setting the table with plates, silverware, and napkins. Add a candle or some flowers for a special touch.

Warm It Up: If your food has cooled down during transport, reheat it in the oven or microwave. Be careful not to overcook it, as this can dry it out.

Add Some Sides: Supplement your carryout meal with some simple sides, such as a salad, garlic bread, or steamed vegetables.

Pair with Wine: Enhance your Italian meal by pairing it with a complementary wine. A Chianti or Pinot Grigio would be excellent choices.

Relax and Enjoy: Finally, sit back, relax, and enjoy your delicious Italian meal. Buon appetito!

Conclusion: Ithaca's Italian Carryout Scene

Ithaca, New York, offers a diverse and delicious Italian carryout scene. Whether you're in the mood for classic pasta dishes, flavorful pizzas, or hearty Italian sandwiches, you're sure to find something to satisfy your cravings. From Pasta Plus to Gorgers Subs to Sal's Pizzeria, Ithaca's Italian carryout restaurants offer quality, convenience, and a taste of Italy. So next time you're looking for a quick and delicious meal on the go, be sure to check out one of these top contenders for the best Italian carryout in Ithaca.

So, there you have it, folks! A comprehensive guide to the best Italian carryout options in Ithaca, New York. Whether you're a student, a local, or just passing through, I hope this article has helped you discover your next favorite Italian meal. Don't forget to check out the mentioned restaurants and explore their menus for even more delicious options. And remember, always support your local businesses! Enjoy your Italian feast!**